AI, Consultation, and Repatriation
The Opportunity
Artificial intelligence offers collections professionals new ways to locate information, synthesize records, and support complex research. In Tribal consultation and repatriation, these tools may reduce administrative burdens and improve access to collections information for institutions to share with Tribal Nations.
Questions
· Could AI identify Tribal Nations with a relationship to a collection, summarize consultation, weigh evidence of cultural affiliation, or draft an institutional determination?
· When does assistance become interpretation, or efficiency displace human judgment?
· What level of AI support is appropriate when dealing with information considered sensitive, secret, or proprietary?
Observations
· Technical capability alone does not establish whether sensitive tasks should be delegated.
· Information shared in consultation may also move beyond its original context. When entered into institutional systems: it can be retained, aggregated, linked to other records, shared, or reused for purposes not anticipated when it was provided.
· Indigenous data sovereignty requires determination of who has authority over how knowledge is:
- Documented
- Interpreted
- Combined
- Retained
- Shared,
- Reused
As well as who can access it.
Answers
Drawing on federal collections management and repatriation practice:
· An examination of the boundaries between appropriate AI assistance and responsibilities grounded in professional judgment, institutional accountability, consultation, and Tribal authority.
· An evaluation of provenance, context, transparency, access, and trust across the information lifecycle.
Bottom line objective
Identifying the delicate between the uses of AI that may genuinely help collections work and the protection of information entrusted to institutions in consultation.